Saturday, 27 June 2009

BARRY PRIOR: QUADROPHENIA'S LOST MOD?



“Here by the sea and sand,
Nothing ever goes as planned,
I just couldn't face going home.”
“Sea and Sand” (From Quadrophenia)

It’s called Saltdean, and I presume the derivation originates from the sulphurous air that permeates the atmosphere from the sea. It’s about five or six miles along the coast from Brighton and unlike its celebrated neighbour, it’s bereft of any of the trappings that you’d expect to find at the seaside; no pier, no cafe, no illuminations or the smell of fish and chips. In fact, aside from an imposing school building that wouldn't be out of place in The Shining, there’s very little here in Saltdean that one could call memorable.

Additionally, it’s early February and with a cold brisk wind blowing in from the Channel, “bracing” is the only superlative I can muster to describe the scene. I find myself a few hundred metres outside of town at Telscombe Cliffs, a rolling collection of green hills and bleak seascapes. I’m parked in a gravel lay-by alongside a busy road. Over to the right, there’s a small patch of grass that save for a modest fence dissolves into a terrifying sheer drop, well over 100 feet in depth. Disturbingly, there are several man-made gaps along the fence’s perimeter, although it’s beyond me why anyone would want to get any closer. The authorities appear ignorant to the state of the cliff’s defences  presumably deeming its extremity an obvious enough deterrent for anyone stupid enough to lark around it. In any case, it’s not really somewhere you would really want to stand that close to, and even if you were into that sort of thing, there are more dramatic drops along the coast at Beachy Head.

I remind myself why I am here. In the spring of 1964, a 17- year-old trainee accountant by the name of Barry Prior fell to his death at this very spot. He’d been down to Brighton with a group of friends from London, to engage in what history now defines as the “Mods and Rockers” riots of the early 1960s. Whether by design or through an act of eerie synchronicity, Barry’s journey is echoed by the album and attendant film version of Quadrophenia, Pete Townshend’s classic paean to teenage angst. The fact that the concept’s protagonist, a similarly aged office worker from London, met his “demise” on a Brighton cliff top haunts me. As far as I’m concerned, these similarities are just far too extraordinary to be an act of coincidence.

I pull out a photocopy of a news feature concerning Barry’s death that I uncovered quite by accident a while back. Within seconds, the dampness in the sea air causes the Xerox to wilt and flap around in the wind. It’s from the Brighton Evening Argus, a provincial daily newspaper that’s as much a fixture of the town as the promenade and pier. I find it incongruous that the story of Barry’s tragic end was relegated alongside the “births, deaths and marriages” section, although given that other events were dominating the front pages, it’s probably not that surprising. Next to the headline, “Mod Falls to Death at Brighton Cliff”, there’s a photograph of Barry’s scooter and a group of sullen youngsters in a huddle around the cliff edge. Presumably, any celebrity they may have accrued in their participation in the weekend’s riotous events had been summarily dispatched by the horror that had unfolded before their eyes.

As one would expect from a local newspaper, it’s pretty stilted in its reporting of the drama. Additionally, as the Argus is a daily issue, the feature was probably thrown together in order to meet the noonday deadline. The article informs me that following an eventful day in Brighton, this group of thrill-seeking Mods arrived at Saltdean around 3am. It wasn't that unusual a decision to pitch base at such a time; Brighton’s moonlight revellers have traditionally sought temporary sanctuary wherever their weary bodies drop, although under the pier or on the beach has always been the preferred spot. However, given these youngsters’ stamina and London sensibility, camping out would have given an added dimension to their weekend away and an extra topic to brag about when they returned home.

What happened in the ensuing hours is a mystery. All that is known is that Barry’s body was discovered shortly after 7am, lying sprawled some 100 feet below on the beach. Colin Goulden, one of Barry’s circle recalled the moment when they discovered that Barry wasn’t where he should be." One of the boys said he was missing and we started looking for him," said a stunned Goulden. "Someone looked over the cliff and saw him lying there. He shouted out, but at first we thought he was mucking about, trying to get us all up.” Fred Butler, another friend from London could hardly bring himself to look at Barry’s scooter as reporters pressed him for an explanation: “I don’t know what could have happened. There was no trouble or fighting. We came out here to get out of the way. Perhaps he got up in the night and went for a walk. No one saw anything and there were no screams.”

Trying to make some sense of this, my immediate thought is that in his bleary state, Barry may well have gone for a pee or some other ablution, misjudged his footing and headed off into the unknown. Presumably, the fence is a recent addition; had it been in place back in 1964 history might well have been different. I gingerly venture forwards and peer over the cliff. It’s absolutely terrifying and offers no respite in its descent to the ground. Barry wouldn't have stood a chance. Poor sod.



I retreat from the cliff edge and look at the rest of the article. It reports that as reality began to dawn, the boys went into a blind panic. “We went over to the houses on the other side of the road to call the police,” recalled one of the lads. “But they wouldn't open their doors at first. They thought we were out for trouble: you know what it is.”

I can only imagine the locals evident horror at their unexpected visitors, especially as the media had sensationally invoked phrases such as: “Marauding army of youths on the rampage” over the weekend. Still, it was a measure of the lads desperation that they were banging randomly on doors, as any shops, garages or phone boxes are even now a fair distance away.

After eventually reporting the incident, Barry’s stunned friends waited for the emergency services to arrive. All the while, Barry’s prized Vespa scooter stood alone, no one daring to go near it. Eventually, ambulance and police reached the site and conferred with Barry’s stunned friends. Eager to be of assistance, the parka- clad group merged with the uniformed personnel and accompanied them the 500 meters around the headland to gain access to the beach. Presumably, any differences the respective parties might have harboured following the weekend’s fracas at Brighton were momentarily shelved as the harrowing descent to the beach begun. One of the youths, either too shaken or terrified to give his name to the Argus, recalled the grisly scene when they approached Barry’s body. “It was horrible,” he said. “He was lying there wearing a green anorak and socks but no shoes. He was horribly bashed up.”

The article concludes that after Barry’s body was taken away by ambulance to hospital, the police took a few of the Mods back to Brighton to fill out witness statements. Following the completion of the necessary paperwork, they were allowed to leave. It must have been a pitiful and sombre retreat back to London, with the impending horror of having to recount Barry’s death to his family weighing heavily on their minds.

I look up, take a deep breath and wander across the green turf to ascertain where the lads’ tents would have been situated. Given the area’s proximity to the cliff, the concept of camping on such a spot seems thoroughly ludicrous; although I concede that the idea was probably based more on fatigue and darkness more than any other factor. As I look around, the sound of the waves crashing against the shoreline invades my mind, and without any prompting, I hear the first few bars of “I Am The Sea”, the opening track on the Quadrophenia album. I wince as I make this association, knowing that in reality this wasn't something as ephemeral as a song or a scene from a movie. It was a real life tragedy, the ripple effects of which would have provoked a torrent of grief throughout Barry’s family and friends.

Slightly shaken by all of this, I reassure myself that I am not here to gawp at some horrendous accident scene, but to determine how real life and fiction have spookily merged. Being here today adds considerable weight to my belief that Pete Townshend must surely have heard about Barry’s death, and that it lodged somewhere in his subconscious before reappearing when he created Quadrophenia. For me as a researcher (and a pretty seasoned one at that), it is this merge of fact and fiction that intrigues me, and if Quadrophenia has a spark or starting point, I feel it is here. I am more than happy to be proven wrong on this, but if I am to treat the story with the seriousness it deserves, I have to determine all the elements that may have informed the story’s creation. With my consciousness dizzying by the rush of visuals and associations I've been making, I wander back to the sanctuary of my car and drive along the coast to more tangible landscapes.



Brighton. The place oozes passion and vitality, and yet there is this indefinable feeling that something less savoury is rattling away in the background. To me, the place is as bright as a fluorescent tube and as brittle as a stick of rock. As any historian worth his salt will tell you, the town has been synonymous with “escaping to” for centuries. From dirty weekends to cheap day returns; from handkerchiefs on the head to fish and chips on the beach, Brighton personifies the risqué better than any other town in the United Kingdom. I sense this as it as I wander along the promenade and later, through the town’s labyrinth of streets. It’s easy to gauge this airborne cheekiness as the smiles and evident cheer outweighs any gloom. Similarly, it’s not that difficult to notice that since 1979, the year of Quadrophenia’s film release, Brighton has been heavily gentrified in line with "New" Labour's vision of Britain, and on every street there are coffee bars, mobile phone shops and gastropubs hugging the kerbs. My inert cynicism informs me there’s almost certainly a back-story to all of this, and that the dark side revealed in the town’s other cinematic landmark Brighton Rock, is still there, it’s just been swept up and pushed back out of view.

I walk past the last vestiges of the Brighton Aquarium, and note the location’s role in Quadrophenia. It may seem shocking to those who value the hearing of marine life, but during the 1960s, the building adjacent to the Aquarium housed the Florida Ballroom, a popular night club and de rigeur stop off point for bands doing the provincial rounds of the UK. The Who frequently played during the mid-1960s, and given its location, the presence of the band would have been a huge draw for music lovers and Mods alike.

The place obviously found favour with Pete Townshend, who dedicated Quadrophenia’s album to those lucky few who attended those Florida Rooms gigs. When pressed on this, Townshend has recalled a seismic event that occurred in his consciousness one blisteringly hot summer night in August 1964. Following a typically frantic Who performance, Pete left the sunken reaches of the venue and perched himself on the promenade to wind down. As he meditated on the sea while having a relaxing smoke, the last few stragglers from the concert made their way up the marble steps to street level. As the faintly metronomic sound of the tide morphed with the strains of Tamla Motown seeping out of the Ballroom, it made for an enchanting aural concoction. As if on cue, a few hardy Mods stepped into their scooters, and drove around in a circular formation before moving off into the darkness. As these disparate elements gradually merged into a moving motion picture, Townshend was entranced. To Townshend, it was the “most perfect moment of my life”, a confirmation of the sort of landscape that had played in his head, but rarely in reality. Elements of this scene are echoed in the film of Quadrophenia, where a group of scooter riders similarly engage in an automated circle dance at first light. As I piece the images together at the same location, it strikes me that this particular experience defined Townshend’s vision for Quadrophenia more than any other factor.

With an array of images floating around my head, I wander down the steps to the Aquarium and walk through a dimly lit tunnel that leads directly onto the beach. As I emerge, I see a young man dressed in a green fur-rimmed parka, sprawled out and gazing aimlessly at the sea. Five minutes later, I walk past a couple of young Mods; no more than 19 or 20, posing on the promenade in their finest garb. It’s evident that the links between Quadrophenia and Brighton are inextricable, and despite the time-slip, Brighton will always be a Mecca for seekers wanting to engage in the residual energy the film has left behind. There’s little doubt that younger generations have learnt about Brighton’s association with Modernism from Quadrophenia more than any other historical source.

I make my way towards the area’s local history library, now housed in the grounds of Brighton’s historic Pavilion. On arriving, I wonder how the librarians are going to respond to my request for any ephemera concerning “Mods and Rockers” riots. My apprehension is increased considerably as I pass various antiquated marble statues and Victorian art works that adorn the walls of the building. I have little to worry about as the friendly librarian informs me that someone had been in earlier to research the period for a dissertation as part of their sociology degree. Additionally, on the walls of the reading room, there’s an enormous photograph depicting a posse of Mods and their scooters alongside Brighton pier in 1964. My, how times have changed.

I’m surprised when the librarian swiftly returns with a folder emblazoned with the legend “Mods and Rockers”. I get the feeling that this is a familiar request, and to save time, the staff has collated this miscellany to avoid the interminable digging through their archives. She hands over the clear plastic folder that contains several hundred clippings from the 1960s, interwoven a few articles detailing Quadrophenia and the activities of latter day Mods. I mention to her about my project to find more information concerning Barry Prior’s story, and although she shows some perfunctory interest in my quest, it’s evident she knows nothing about it. Not for the first time, I wonder if it is just me who has made this connection.

I lay the yellowing newsprint over a table and gaze at the scene before me. The cuttings tell in typically sensational detail how the May 1964 battle took hold, and how the police vainly tried to shepherd the warring elements around town. Given the magnitude of events, many of Brighton’s crustier locals interpreted the situation as a call to arms. Utilising phraseology that would put a Dad’s Army script to shame, a legion of retired army personnel actively called for vigilante groups to patrol the area lest it descended into further chaos. Deeper within the collection of clippings, there are numerous reports on the court sessions that were convened to process the litany of offences from the riots. It was at these hearings that the establishment finally got its revenge on these dissident elements, as outraged magistrates handed out exemplary sentences accompanied with the sort of semantics that wouldn't be out of place in a Greek tragedy. I notice that some of the dialogue from the courtroom actually made its way into the film version of Quadrophenia verbatim. I’m impressed; the researchers had evidently put in the legwork and yet knowing this, I can’t believe for one moment that they hadn't come across Barry’s story at some point.

As I replace the clippings back in the folder, I’m still in need of further information to qualify my assumptions regarding Barry’s death. I feel ill equipped with just one article to hand after all my researches. In desperation, I hedge a bet that there may have been a follow-up report later in the week, and I turn to the microfiche reader to scan the area’s sister paper, the Brighton Herald, for any possible nuggets of information.

As the Herald had failed to report on Barry’s death, I’m surprised that a few days later, it eavesdropped on the Coroner's inquest into the tragedy. Again, it’s buried deep in the paper, and it makes for fairly dismal reading. Instinctively, I nod my head when I read that the Coroner shared my belief that Barry may well have wandered off to relieve himself before falling to his death. Assured that there was no foul play or intent to commit suicide present, a verdict of “death by misadventure” was recorded. The rest of the feature tells me little I didn’t already know, save for one small fact. Given the force of Barry’s descent, his wristwatch was torn off as he fell. It was later found and identified as his. Poignantly, the watch had stopped at the precise time he hit the ground: 3.50 a.m.

Barry's tragic death would understandably haunt his family in the years that followed. The modest coverage afforded to his death in the local media ensured the event was soon superseded by other news. Outside of the considerable family trauma, notices of Barry's death would be preserved in the archives of the local newspaper and library.

Come 1978,a sustained revisit of the period was made by script-writer Martin Stellman. Commissioned to write and re-write a lot of the Quadrophenia script, Stellman - a former journalist - diligently went through the cuttings files in London and Brighton libraries, and predictably came across the story of Barry Prior.

Stellman clearly felt the story had echoes with Pete Townshend's concept, and while the"Jimmy" in the album concept stole a boat and headed off to sea for the story's coda, it appears that elements of Barry Prior's demise were to be utilised for the closing moments of the story. Scene 170 of the shooting script clearly lists "Rottingdean" as the start of Jimmy's clifftop adventure, and with Rottingdean a little under two miles from the location of Barry's tragic death, it is clear that the end was initially envisaged to be there and not Beachy Head (some 18 miles further along the coast.)


Once Quadrophenia hit the cinema screens in 1979, no one drew any parallels between Barry's death and Jimmy's on-screen demise (however nebulous it may have seemed). However, over the ensuing years word of Barry's untimely passing started to be referenced in relation to Quadrophenia. In a 2003 (and with the film undergoing a sharp renaissance),  director Franc Roddam made a startling admission to a journalist which appeared to connect Quadrophenia's origins with Barry's death. What made the quote more sensational is that Roddam claimed that Pete Townshend had told him during the making of the film that he had been inspired to write Quadrophenia after reading an article about a "young mod" who'd "committed suicide" at Beachy Head during 1964. While it is clear that Barry did not commit suicide and that he died several miles away from Beachy Head, it is clear that the two episodes were already linked. When I quizzed Townshend on this in 2001 he claimed he knew nothing of Barry's death and directed me to the album concept that was his vision and creation, where Jimmy patently didn't kill himself.

But aside from the inferences between the two elements, probably the most startling revelation to come out of this story is that Barry's brother in later years would end up working for The Who's management team during the 1970s, being present during the making of Quadrophenia. While Prior and his family have stayed friends with Townshend to this day, there has been no word whether the subject of Barry Prior has ever been raised in relation to the story. 

Over half a century on from this tragedy, there's no real hard facts (other than Roddam's claim) to suggest that this young man's death inspired Pete Townshend to write Quadrophenia. But what is more than clear is that Barry Prior was a pivotal component in Franc Roddam's vision for the film. For all of his short life and tragic death, it is perhaps fitting that Barry now has his place in Quadrophenia and Mod history. 








© Simon Wells 2009 (updated 2015/2016)



12 comments:

  1. Real life tragedy feeding into music and movies. What feeds Brighton's cultural life these days though? The homogenous effect of students and refugees from London has left it lacking the energy and vibe the city still claims to possess.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I believe it's safe to say you're completely wrong in your assumption that Barry Prior's story influenced Pete Townshend's writing of the Quadrophenia album or film.

    Firstly, there is *no* part in the story on the album where anybody goes over a cliff on a scooter and dies. The hero of the album brings the story to a close by stealing a boat and sailing out to a rock.

    Just to digress briefly for argument's sake, I also think it incredibly unlikely Pete Townshend heard of Barry Prior's death when it happened.

    Barry Prior died on May 18th, 1964. On April the 18th The Who gave their last Brighton performance before the death. They didn't return to play Brighton again until June 7th.
    So the sad event occurred slap in the middle of a period when The Who were most defintely out of town.

    As you yourself point out, the Barry Prior death report was "relegated alongside the births, deaths and marriages" section of a "provincial daily newspaper". So with Townshend not being in Brighton 2 or 3 weeks either side of the death, what is the likelyhood of him having seen that copy of the Argus, let alone seeing the death report stashed away in the back pages?

    You could argue someone showed him a copy of the paper, but the vast majority of Mods attending those Who concerts were from outside of Brighton, kids who travelled down for the day or the weekend. So how likely is it a local Mod who'd read the story would have kept a copy to show to Townshend when The Who returned 3 weeks later?

    Now to the possibilty of the Barry Prior story having influenced Townshend's writing of the Quadrophenia film. It *would* comfortably fit the timeline, in theory Townshend could have heard the story belatedly (anytime between 1964 and 1973) and taken influence from it for inclusion in the script.

    One problem. Franc Roddam wrote the film treatment of Quadrophenia, not Pete Townshend. Townshend merely sent Roddam a copy of the Quadrophenia album by way of explaining the story - the same album which, remember, had no mention of scooters going over cliffs.

    Despite all of that, I *do* agree there *is* a likelyhood of the Barry Prior story having influenced the film, but in no manner more mystical or exotic than that which brought you to discover it.

    There are a number of scenes and slices of dialogue in Quadrophenia which mirror contemporay press reports or photographs of the Mod/Rocker happenings in Brighton during the early 1960s. So clearly Roddam had researchers burrowing around in the archives before starting work on his script. And just as you found the Barry Prior story in the Brighton library, a researcher found that same story 20 years earlier and passed it on to Roddam with a number of other clippings and cuttings.

    It's as simple as that. At least with your blog Barry Prior has to a certain extent now been granted his rightful place in Mod history.

    Rest easy Barry.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think it's wrong to say that what Simon Wells says is untrue, as you can offer no evidence to prove him wrong other than your own theories. Pete Townshend has offered various reasons for Quadrophenia and it's birth like sleeping under the pier - The sitting outside after a Gig and seeing the scooters driving around a single Mod amongst other things. Who's to say it never made the news elsewhere radio? etc. Who's to say Pete wasn't told about it? I personally feel within the album Pete tells us about himself and the other members Whatever the theories into the albums birth that's what makes it more the special it's not fake something knocked up over a couple of months, it's something that grew over the years to the point Pete had to put it down, it almost broke him making the album all the above just lead to a great foundation to an absolute beautiful album.

      Delete
  3. Dear Mr. Wells,
    first of all thank you so much for posting this, as somebody else said the poor Barry at least has been granted his rightful place in Mod history. On the other hand I allow myself to suggest you to investigate another tragic mod story reported on page 3 of the Daily Mirror, Wednesday, August 5, 1964 (by the way the day I was born):

    "Dead boy may have been pushed over cliff"
    the story of James Smart, 14, the Mod whose body was found in the sea of Hastings. I'm typing hereunder a short part of the article (you may find anyway at page 81 on the bottom left of Terry Rawlings' MOD a very british phenomenon):

    "The 14 year old Mod washed up on Hastings beach at the week end may have been thrown into the sea during a clifftop fight between Mods and Rockers..."

    Thank for your kind attention
    All the best
    Marco

    ReplyDelete
  4. Dear Marco,
    Thanks for sharing this story, it is extraordinary. At present though, I am just saddened that two young men lost their lives over these weekends.
    Regards
    Simon

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hi Simon, I don't know if you still check comments to this blog but wanted to let you know that Barry was my uncle. My brother came across this blog and just sent me the link. My dad was Barry's younger brother - they were inseparable and my dad has spent his life in such heartbreak ever since Barry's death. I was really touched by your sensitivity as you wrote. And strangely, my dad ended up managing The Who for years and even worked on the Quadrophenia project with Pete Townshend (whose family we are friends with). It was such a tragedy the way Barry died but what was awful, from what I understand, was how the press claimed it was a suicide, when our family knew how happy and content he was and that it must have been an accident - exactly as you said. My grandfather still won't read newspapers to this day... (he is now in his 90's). Very best wishes to you, Hollie

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Dear Hollie - thank you so much for getting in touch. I sensed when I came across this story many years ago that there a larger picture to be drawn - especially given the details of young Barry's life. Putting aside the ephemeral world of pop music and youth cults, this is a tragic story of a young man losing his life in such a sad fashion. I'm so sorry that Barry's death has such a devastating effect on your family over the years. I can only trust that my attempt at presenting a rounder picture of your uncle acts as a sensitive memorial to his short life.

      Feel free to contact me off board at simoncatweazleATaol.com

      Regards

      Simon

      Delete
  6. Odd story. I am shaken by this young mans death, & am not sure whether I agree with the coroners verdict of the day. Do watches tear off as one descends down the face of a cliff ? Or is it torn off in a fight before a young man is pushed/ thrown off the cliff face, with the watch going over after him ? If he landed on his front then he must have gone over that way. Of course, it may be innocent; trip, stumble & fall, but the watch throws it for me. Thanks for the piece, Simon. As usual a challenging, exceptionally well written essay.

    ReplyDelete
  7. As a young Mod revivalist back in the late 70's courtesy of Quad. We had heard this story and all thought it was a rumour or folklore. I always wondered if there was any substance in the story a the time. A very sad story and a tragic loss of life. Frank Roddam does mention this event on the clip below @3 mins 40 secs if you want to skip. In summary a really sad loss of life R.I.P a real shame that this young man is still not with us.


    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cImgEDD3v0M

    ReplyDelete
  8. Jimmy dosnt go off the cliff in quadrophenia, only the scooter go's over, the beginning of the film ware he is seen walking towards the camera is infact the end.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That's very true - but the original idea was for him to go over the cliff - it was only at the last minute, during filming, that they decided to go with him walking away. Franc Roddam talks about it here.... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cImgEDD3v0M

      Delete